Argonath RPG - A World of its own

GTA:SA => SA:MP - San Andreas Multiplayer => SA:MP General => Topic started by: Mikal on October 05, 2014, 04:09:06 pm

Title: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Mikal on October 05, 2014, 04:09:06 pm
Which is it? No managers have said anything and the server can barely stay online.. :(
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: TiMoN on October 05, 2014, 04:15:43 pm
Bet it's a ddos, a few people told me it was.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Dadial_Singh on October 05, 2014, 04:54:51 pm
Please Do something These Ddos or wat ever attacks r making various mission failed
While growing drugs
Or RP
Server hangs and restarts
Even losses health and weapon and last position :(
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Mikal on October 05, 2014, 04:59:22 pm
The server seems to be online and stable for the moment..
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Slavik on October 05, 2014, 05:04:43 pm
Even losses health and weapon and last position :(
This happens when the first login attempt has failed. On the second attempt you will lose health/weapons/last position
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Rei on October 05, 2014, 05:14:12 pm
This happens when the first login attempt has failed. On the second attempt you will lose health/weapons/last position
This happen to me almost "everytime" i login into server..
I've never mistaked my login code and still happend!
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: TiMoN on October 05, 2014, 05:15:26 pm
This happens when the first login attempt has failed. On the second attempt you will lose health/weapons/last position
I never fail a login attempt.


This usually happens to me when I /q right after entering your password(before you spawn).
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Mikal on October 05, 2014, 05:15:45 pm
Back offline again, and really laggy if it comes on...
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Dadial_Singh on October 05, 2014, 05:16:01 pm
Oh i see :O
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Spike. on October 05, 2014, 05:18:05 pm
It looks like MTA:SA working just fine.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: TiMoN on October 05, 2014, 05:41:01 pm
Everyone donate some money so we can put a hit contract on that attacker, it's getting boring.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Lustigkurre on October 05, 2014, 07:38:31 pm
Why not use Gimlis server? I heard it has better protection.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Mikal on October 05, 2014, 07:45:18 pm
Why not use Gimlis server? I heard it has better protection.
Why use Gimli's server when we can just blame him for the DDoS? :gand:
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: TiMoN on October 05, 2014, 07:52:59 pm
Why not use Gimlis server? I heard it has better protection.
that, and my idea would really work out
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Mr. Goobii on October 05, 2014, 08:15:39 pm
Why not use Gimlis server? I heard it has better protection.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Dadial_Singh on October 06, 2014, 07:32:58 am
Only few players less than 15 appear online
Its too boaring ........
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Khm on October 06, 2014, 08:19:32 am
Only few players less than 15 appear online
Its too boaring ........
Its 7am lol
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: AK47 on October 06, 2014, 12:30:47 pm
Why not use Gimlis server? I heard it has better protection.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Skalleper on October 06, 2014, 12:32:06 pm
It looks like MTA:SA working just fine.

Too bad the topic has nothing to do with it, go post that on your own forum because you are so special.



Why not use Gimlis server? I heard it has better protection.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: .Matthew. on October 06, 2014, 03:09:21 pm
Yesterday evening alot of SAMP servers went down (Specially on my favorite list) and host provider on SAMP forums said that OVH had problems with firewall or something.
That's a possibility.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Luke on October 06, 2014, 04:18:16 pm
Why not use Gimlis server? I heard it has better protection.

Believe it or not we are currently using Gimli's server, hence every time it goes down, Me and Brian have to contact him to get it back up again.

Last night I believe there was some issues with SAMP in general and the tabs within the client, probably due to this the server had issues. Just a heads up, when we have issues within the server try not to assume its a attack or "you know who".
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Bundy on October 06, 2014, 04:57:53 pm
Just a heads up, when we have issues within the server try not to assume its a attack or "you know who".
Unfortunately most of the time it's one of those two. :)
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Mikal on October 06, 2014, 04:58:59 pm
We wouldn't have to run round like headless chickens saying "DDoS?" if HQ would give us a heads up on what's happening..
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Dadial_Singh on October 07, 2014, 03:31:24 pm
Hail oh sauron
Protect Samp Argonath from all evil :janek:
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Seskom on October 09, 2014, 04:07:43 pm
aaand again management does not communicate or explain what's going on to the players as they sit in dark :/
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: danipoz on October 09, 2014, 04:14:23 pm
We wouldn't have to run round like headless chickens saying "DDoS?" if HQ would give us a heads up on what's happening..
Exactly..
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Mikal on October 09, 2014, 05:25:15 pm
aaand again management does not communicate or explain what's going on to the players as they sit in dark :/
As much as I like Argonath, it has to be said that it's both the players and the management failing the server, there is no communication which is why so many have left, it is why so many have just given up, it doesn't look like anything is being done to improve anything anymore.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Devin on October 09, 2014, 06:01:34 pm
aaand again management does not communicate or explain what's going on to the players as they sit in dark :/

So what do you want to know? The server goes down - Due to a ddos attack.
What else is there to say? My hands are tied.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Mikal on October 09, 2014, 06:11:43 pm
So what do you want to know? The server goes down - Due to a ddos attack.
What else is there to say? My hands are tied.
It's not just about the server going down though, there's no updates on what bugs are being fixed or what other things are going to be implemented, it feels like all the people in influential positions can no longer be bothered.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: jovanca on October 09, 2014, 06:44:30 pm
My hands are tied.

Kinky
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Seskom on October 10, 2014, 01:20:59 am
So what do you want to know? The server goes down - Due to a ddos attack.
What else is there to say? My hands are tied.

On most occasions nothing is told to players. They just sit and wait in the dark.
Proper action would be to post an information somewhere regarding downtime whih for example should contain following:
Reason server is down: e.g. Script error crashed the server
What's going to happen next: e.g. Cretain script is getting removed
How long it will estimately take to get the server up and running again: e.g. soon as we get hold of <enter a name here> which is approximately in 3 hours.

This would get communication between the managers and players, people woudln't be sitting around wondering when it's gonna be up or if it's gonna take 2 weeks again for him to be able to play again. This is the attitude which makes people leave, they are not informed about server related issues which results in not understandment, but more likely anger and people making up shit accusations.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Chris_Knight on October 10, 2014, 11:06:04 am
I can't believe the need of playing GTA is so strong, that people are so obsessed  with it. If you are so into games , there is always more out there. If you are so into talking ,for that you got specificly made websites and programms .
If you have other hobbies, spare time on it or do something else besides spaming forum how hard it is and how much you feel harmed about server being down. After ddosers come and make fun of you all and encourage them ddos even more.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Seskom on October 10, 2014, 12:08:57 pm
I can't believe the need of playing GTA is so strong, that people are so obsessed  with it. If you are so into games , there is always more out there. If you are so into talking ,for that you got specificly made websites and programms .
If you have other hobbies, spare time on it or do something else besides spaming forum how hard it is and how much you feel harmed about server being down. After ddosers come and make fun of you all and encourage them ddos even more.
I'm not really obsessed with it, it's just that constantly when I try to join the server is down and I'm unable to play, yet theres 0 information regarding why or how long it will last on forums.

Lately I've been getting the feeling I'm suprised when Argonath is up and running when it should be vise versa.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Chris_Knight on October 10, 2014, 12:28:09 pm
I'm not really obsessed with it, it's just that constantly when I try to join the server is down and I'm unable to play, yet theres 0 information regarding why or how long it will last on forums.

Lately I've been getting the feeling I'm suprised when Argonath is up and running when it should be vise versa.
DDos happens almost on daily basis ,if server would go down for any different reason I asume HQ would notify. Other than that the issue is mainstream.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: .Matthew. on October 10, 2014, 02:11:08 pm
I can't believe the need of playing GTA is so strong, that people are so obsessed  with it. If you are so into games , there is always more out there. If you are so into talking ,for that you got specificly made websites and programms .
If you have other hobbies, spare time on it or do something else besides spaming forum how hard it is and how much you feel harmed about server being down. After ddosers come and make fun of you all and encourage them ddos even more.
Parallel universe.

In most "other" communities, management tries to keep and motivate players to stay, meanwhile in Argonath "there are so many more games... what are you waiting for? GO!"
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Seskom on October 10, 2014, 06:00:35 pm
Matthew raised a great point actually-...

Argonath as a server is trying to gain players right now and trying to advertise, yet when server goes down nothing is done and players are asked to go play another games or do something else. That just makes them interested in either other SA:MP server or another game which will get them hooked and they have no desire to return. Specially if this happens constantly as it is going on right now.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: BJoker on October 10, 2014, 06:11:12 pm
Matthew raised a great point actually-...

Argonath as a server is trying to gain players right now and trying to advertise, yet when server goes down nothing is done and players are asked to go play another games or do something else. That just makes them interested in either other SA:MP server or another game which will get them hooked and they have no desire to return. Specially if this happens constantly as it is going on right now.
Point man, This is why we always having like 50/45 players and in just holidays we have like 60 players
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Mikal on October 10, 2014, 08:41:18 pm
Might aswell just stab Argonath in the neck and be done with it, nobody can be bothered anymore, not even 'HQ'.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Devin on October 10, 2014, 10:45:23 pm
Might aswell just stab Argonath in the neck and be done with it, nobody can be bothered anymore, not even 'HQ'.

And what makes you say that? I wouldn't be on the forum if I didn't care.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Chris_Knight on October 10, 2014, 10:50:34 pm
I am not an sales manager to offer you an product, if you are unable hold your self and stop creating topics every time ddos happens with OMG HQ doesn't cares talk, then offering you anything else is a good choice, yes.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Demir. on October 10, 2014, 11:01:01 pm
Is "world.argonathrpg.eu:7777" Argonaths IP ???
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: AK47 on October 10, 2014, 11:06:05 pm
Is "world.argonathrpg.eu:7777" Argonaths IP ???

It's down, d o w n
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Mikal on October 10, 2014, 11:07:53 pm
And what makes you say that? I wouldn't be on the forum if I didn't care.
I'm not saying you don't care Devin, I like your style of managing - You're not a scripter and you're not the server owner though, and it's them 2 'groups' that seem to keep everyone in the dark on everything, when was the last time a scripter posted in bug reports? To us players it looks like nothing us being done and nothing is being improved.

I am not an sales manager to offer you an product, if you are unable hold your self and stop creating topics every time ddos happens with OMG HQ doesn't cares talk, then offering you anything else is a good choice, yes.
This wasn't an "OMG DDOS HELP US" topic, this was a topic to try to find out what is continuously happening and if anything is being done to stop it..

Is "world.argonathrpg.eu:7777" Argonaths IP ???
Yes but the server is currently using a temp IP which is offline for now.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Demir. on October 10, 2014, 11:10:33 pm
It's down, d o w n

is This Magic then ??

(http://i59.tinypic.com/2u43rdc.jpg)
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: AK47 on October 10, 2014, 11:11:37 pm
is This Magic then ??

(http://i59.tinypic.com/2u43rdc.jpg)

wow ser if it wurks why u ask here den
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Demir. on October 10, 2014, 11:12:55 pm
wow ser if it wurks why u ask here den

i asked that The IP of argonath is world.argonathrpg.eu:7777 , i didnt asked it is working or not.


Thanks.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Seskom on October 11, 2014, 02:12:04 am
And what makes you say that? I wouldn't be on the forum if I didn't care.

Yes Devin, you care, but perhaps you could answer some of the issues brought up in this topic as you're active. I'm referring to :

On most occasions nothing is told to players. They just sit and wait in the dark.
Proper action would be to post an information somewhere regarding downtime whih for example should contain following:
Reason server is down: e.g. Script error crashed the server
What's going to happen next: e.g. Cretain script is getting removed
How long it will estimately take to get the server up and running again: e.g. soon as we get hold of <enter a name here> which is approximately in 3 hours.

This would get communication between the managers and players, people woudln't be sitting around wondering when it's gonna be up or if it's gonna take 2 weeks again for him to be able to play again. This is the attitude which makes people leave, they are not informed about server related issues which results in not understandment, but more likely anger and people making up shit accusations.

Parallel universe.

In most "other" communities, management tries to keep and motivate players to stay, meanwhile in Argonath "there are so many more games... what are you waiting for? GO!"

Also there are new topics created regarding downtime by players, yet none by management to avoid those topics and inform us instead of having the community to try to get answers on their own.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Devin on October 11, 2014, 02:50:21 am
On most occasions nothing is told to players. They just sit and wait in the dark.
Proper action would be to post an information somewhere regarding downtime whih for example should contain following:
Reason server is down: e.g. Script error crashed the server
What's going to happen next: e.g. Cretain script is getting removed
How long it will estimately take to get the server up and running again: e.g. soon as we get hold of <enter a name here> which is approximately in 3 hours.

This would get communication between the managers and players, people woudln't be sitting around wondering when it's gonna be up or if it's gonna take 2 weeks again for him to be able to play again. This is the attitude which makes people leave, they are not informed about server related issues which results in not understandment, but more likely anger and people making up shit accusations.

RS5 on the 92.222.221.246:7777 address is no longer online/hosted there and we will be moving the server back to the Argonath (main) host as soon as possible.
Unfortunately I am not able to give you a timeframe on the completion time or date.

As for script changes, I don't have any control over that. It's a developers ordeal to handle and inform the players of up and coming changes.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Frank_Hawk on October 11, 2014, 11:44:26 am
In hindsight, I wish the SA:MP community had applied the same diligence shown in RS5 to enhanced server protection instead.

RS4's game mode would have been perfect with no lag and better server protection.

Nevertheless, we are what we are.

What can we do to implement a long term strategic fix?

Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: .Matthew. on October 11, 2014, 08:01:11 pm
Ah, most of you don't know how depressive it is to be DDoSed and how helpless you are.
It's like being boxed between 4 walls and you can't go anywhere.

Specially nowadays in SAMP when every 12year old gets his hands on all kinds of devices and tools with which he can do it.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Mikal on October 11, 2014, 08:28:18 pm
Ah, most of you don't know how depressive it is to be DDoSed and how helpless you are.
It's like being boxed between 4 walls and you can't go anywhere.

Specially nowadays in SAMP when every 12year old gets his hands on all kinds of devices and tools with which he can do it.
These '12 year olds' should be easily detected by ISP's and shut offline, if they are not then clearly they are not 12 year olds with petty programmes.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: .Matthew. on October 11, 2014, 09:57:13 pm
These '12 year olds' should be easily detected by ISP's and shut offline, if they are not then clearly they are not 12 year olds with petty programmes.
Proxies.

There are governmental services being attacked and half of them don't find the attacker(s).
Then imagine your chances in 2004 game.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Seskom on October 26, 2014, 07:51:29 pm
Once again the server is down and nobody knows anything.
What happened?
When will it be up?
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Rusty on October 26, 2014, 07:56:41 pm
Once again the server is down and nobody knows anything.
What happened?
When will it be up?

Unknown
Unknown

Does that answer your question? 
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: [NP]Monte Montague on October 26, 2014, 09:01:14 pm
Unknown
Unknown

Does that answer your question? 
This would be more appropriate :)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cHcunREYzNY
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Seskom on October 26, 2014, 09:18:51 pm
Unknown
Unknown

Does that answer your question?

No it really does not.
How is it possible, that when a server goes down NOBODY (including the management) has any idea what happened?
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Cyril on October 26, 2014, 09:29:16 pm
No it really does not.
How is it possible, that when a server goes down NOBODY (including the management) has any idea what happened?

Maybe because we don't have access to server logs therefore we can't know why it goes down?
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Rusty on October 26, 2014, 09:33:48 pm
No it really does not.
How is it possible, that when a server goes down NOBODY (including the management) has any idea what happened?

That's to bad then cause that's the only answer we can give.
It's possible since person who has access to the server isn't exactly around so we can't really know what is up.  That's what happens when certain people should have access to the server don't, we just sit and wait.  No point getting salty over this though everything turns into a drama nowadays.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Bundy on October 26, 2014, 09:40:53 pm
That's to bad then cause that's the only answer we can give.
It's possible since person who has access to the server isn't exactly around so we can't really know what is up.  That's what happens when certain people should have access to the server don't, we just sit and wait.  No point getting salty over this though everything turns into a drama nowadays.
Then why isn't ''that person who isn't around'' giving the appropriate people access? Isn't that the most logical thing to do in such situations?  :v:
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: .Matthew. on October 26, 2014, 09:46:28 pm
Then why isn't ''that person who isn't around'' giving the appropriate people access? Isn't that the most logical thing to do in such situations?  :v:
It be like:

Manager: hey, your server went down
- My server?
Manager: yes..?
- Since when do I....OH THAT
- What's the IP again? and do we have forums?
*Manager on forums* Unknown why it's down. Just forget it and wait.
- What did you say, what's the forum url again?
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Devin on October 26, 2014, 09:52:34 pm
It be like:

Manager: hey, your server went down
- My server?
Manager: yes..?
- Since when do I....OH THAT
- What's the IP again? and do we have forums?
*Manager on forums* Unknown why it's down. Just forget it and wait.
- What did you say, what's the forum url again?

Cocky Player: Hi ur server is down and you dont know why, pls resign
Manager: Speak to Gandalf.

Happy?
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Rusty on October 26, 2014, 09:54:00 pm
Then why isn't ''that person who isn't around'' giving the appropriate people access? Isn't that the most logical thing to do in such situations?  :v:

*shrugs*
Pretty much all I can say for that.



Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Pandalink on October 26, 2014, 10:01:25 pm
Cocky Player: Hi ur server is down and you dont know why, pls resign
Manager: Speak to Gandalf.

Happy?
I like that you gave your example player shitty spelling & grammar and immediately strawmanned them with the very first word of your post, that's a really nice touch.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Miller786 on October 26, 2014, 10:05:42 pm
jumped on the forums to take a look around and guess what? argo argo you never change xD
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Lustigkurre on October 26, 2014, 10:39:30 pm
aaaaaaand down again.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Spike. on October 26, 2014, 10:52:39 pm
SA:MP, MTA:SA and IV:MP down. I believe VC:MP is also down.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: kewlguy13x on October 26, 2014, 11:02:32 pm
Forum being DDoSed as well.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: clancker on October 26, 2014, 11:36:27 pm
This happens for years now and no body actually takes a real action to make it stop.
Well we were told not long ago that the server and forums security were improved and where is the improvement since it happens again and again somebody should really start work and get the things back in line RS4 was constantly getting DDoS now happens the same thing with RS5 which is much more bugged version currently and the constant DDoS won't help in any way solving the bugs and getting the players enjoy there game somebody in this community should start working and currently no body does everybody is standing and looking at the problems but doesn't do a thing to solve them.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Rusty on October 26, 2014, 11:46:16 pm
This happens for years now and no body actually takes a real action to make it stop.
Well we were told not long ago that the server and forums security were improved and where is the improvement since it happens again and again somebody should really start work and get the things back in line RS4 was constantly getting DDoS now happens the same thing with RS5 which is much more bugged version currently and the constant DDoS won't help in any way solving the bugs and getting the players enjoy there game somebody in this community should start working and currently no body does everybody is standing and looking at the problems but doesn't do a thing to solve them.

Because you can't really stop it, Gimli tried when he set-up his server and it still occurred.  But if you have a great idea to make it stop then by all means do share it with the owner.  Separate server has been set-up to find bugs and fix them on, check the SA:MP Ideas board.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: _FreezingDark_ on October 26, 2014, 11:58:11 pm
i hope his gets fixed, and that it doesnt happen again...
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Luke on October 26, 2014, 11:59:07 pm
Seems weird how only certain are down, and the forum is not, I may be the only one, but could the host who hosts our servers have issues.

The game severs are different to the TS and Forum servers. Meaning that if it was DDOS like before, we would have everything brought down.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Khm on October 27, 2014, 12:54:50 am
The improvement in tbe security won't really affect, it will just slow it down netherless a heavy attack or not. The only way to stop this is by having someone who's really able to make FBI look into this crap. A hacker is just a hacker...
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Seskom on October 27, 2014, 01:40:56 am
That's to bad then cause that's the only answer we can give.
It's possible since person who has access to the server isn't exactly around so we can't really know what is up.  That's what happens when certain people should have access to the server don't, we just sit and wait.  No point getting salty over this though everything turns into a drama nowadays.
I belive that's a point managers should raise with Gandalf themselves, we as community are unaware what rights managers do have and which ones they'd require in addition. If you're leader of the community you should be able to negoitate with the owner of the server yourself and explain why such action is required. Not everything turns into a drama, but 21st century is period of logistics basically, everything is expected to work smoothly, that means when something happens there's notification from managers and people get to work on the problem right away. This is not the WWI when shit goes south you just sit in the bunker and wait, perhaps the backup is comming, perhaps it's not, who knows, nobody cares (if you count out the guys sitting in the bunker and trying to survive ofcourse).

Communication between management and the community is crucial, if you don't give a fuck about the players and tell them to play another game until server is down then they'll leave and find next community where they are treated better.

Cocky Player: Hi ur server is down and you dont know why, pls resign
Manager: Speak to Gandalf.

Happy?
Jumping right to assault position and basically disrespecting the player who posted previvious post by trying to make him look like a noob  (grammar mistakes etc.) To be honest that's not really what manager should be doing.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: [NP]Monte Montague on October 27, 2014, 01:47:19 am
Gandalf, Argonath is suffering because you're gone.
Sir, have you given up on us?

Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: .Matthew. on October 27, 2014, 07:18:34 am
Yes, it's true DDoS/DoS attacks can't be completely stopped.
There are some good dedicated servers out there with better protection which filters most of the attack.
But that would cost more money and there's no way to tell if it'll stop every attack, because the attacks can have different strength.
Then, donations are probably low because they do not give any rewards for the player and abilities.
Majority donates to get some abilities and some rewards.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Devin on October 27, 2014, 10:15:46 am
I belive that's a point managers should raise with Gandalf themselves

And this is what we have been trying to do for the past two years. There's no point in players trying to tell us how to do our jobs.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Tiny on October 27, 2014, 12:13:52 pm
I understand that managers do not have the access to check what's happening with the server, but really. Doesn't anyone have contact with Gandalf so they can find a way to organize the server in a more proper way? All the "small" problems we have, plus the downtimes, the attacks, etc are a good way to keep the playerbase down.

If we want to get people here, we gotta first organize in order to keep the current ones. Gandalf should start working a bit more on the server (Sorry if he is, he hasn't shown any signs lately) so we have something great to show to people, so we can attract them. There are great projects like the Advertisment team, but we really can't advertise something incompleted. Props to Chase for what he has started, it's a really good step on getting the server on its feet.

I'd ask the appropriate people to start working a bit harder, and we will all help in any way. It really isn't hard if we all somehow put some effort!
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Cyril on October 27, 2014, 12:17:06 pm
DDoS protection are extremely expensive yet we don't know if they are really efficient.
Gandalf isn't millionaire. He already pays for a lots of servers for us to play for free.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Stivi on October 27, 2014, 12:39:09 pm
Gandalf isn't millionaire.
Just Russian.

Also, going around saying we don't have protection is just bad, makes us even more vulnerable to hacker.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Lustigkurre on October 27, 2014, 12:42:24 pm
Okay then, we'll have to live with constant attacks. There is nothing to do. Now once we got that clear, we can focus on other things.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Luke on October 27, 2014, 01:11:53 pm
DDoS protection are extremely expensive yet we don't know if they are really efficient.
Gandalf isn't millionaire. He already pays for a lots of servers for us to play for free.

Exactly my point also, why would you moan about something you get for free as it is? There is other servers out there that charge players with memberships to play etc. for example, instead of paying 10k to change your name you have to pay a small fee. So in all bid yourselves lucky, because I myself am grateful that we don't have to pay.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Cyril on October 27, 2014, 01:24:13 pm
If you want we can charge you 2$ for a changename, 5$ for a vehicle license and so on. So Gandalf would be able to get better protections.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Marcel on October 27, 2014, 02:46:28 pm
If you want we can charge you 2$ for a changename, 5$ for a vehicle license and so on. So Gandalf would be able to get better protections.
For around €50 a month, you can get a decent dedicated server with great DDoS protection. That is nothing compared to the hundreds that are being spent right now.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: SugarD on October 27, 2014, 02:55:23 pm
Just Russian.

Also, going around saying we don't have protection is just bad, makes us even more vulnerable to hacker.
We have protection from certain attacks. We just don't have military-grade, Fortune 500 corporate anti-DDoS protection.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Marcel on October 27, 2014, 03:04:53 pm
We have protection from certain attacks. We just don't have military-grade, Fortune 500 corporate anti-DDoS protection.
Fortune 500 companies rely on protection as offered by companies such as Tilera and ArborNetworks. At OVH, those protections are also being used. And all that for €50 a month.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: .Matthew. on October 27, 2014, 07:52:31 pm
Fortune 500 companies rely on protection as offered by companies such as Tilera and ArborNetworks. At OVH, those protections are also being used. And all that for €50 a month.
My friend has OVH VPS, 2.00€, to be precise: 1.99€
He's soon getting a dedi for 9€ (+9€ for setup one time).
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Rusty on October 27, 2014, 08:00:05 pm
I belive that's a point managers should raise with Gandalf themselves, we as community are unaware what rights managers do have and which ones they'd require in addition. If you're leader of the community you should be able to negoitate with the owner of the server yourself and explain why such action is required. Not everything turns into a drama, but 21st century is period of logistics basically, everything is expected to work smoothly, that means when something happens there's notification from managers and people get to work on the problem right away. This is not the WWI when shit goes south you just sit in the bunker and wait, perhaps the backup is comming, perhaps it's not, who knows, nobody cares (if you count out the guys sitting in the bunker and trying to survive ofcourse).

Why should I raise a point with Gandalf when my position as a Manager is to look after the Administration Team, issues with server going down is not my area.  Managers don't need access to the server directly as we don't need it and won't ever have it.  We aren't developers or Community Leaders we simply monitor and deal with issues relating to Staff (Moderators, Administrators and players for that matter).  People don't need to know what rights Managers have or don't it's not for you to know yet I just explained what we're tasked to do.

You think everything is expected to work smoothly?  What year you living in 2040? 
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Demir. on October 27, 2014, 08:02:44 pm
Why should I raise a point with Gandalf when my position as a Manager is to look after the Administration Team, issues with server going down is not my area.  Managers don't need access to the server directly as we don't need it and won't ever have it.  We aren't developers or Community Leaders we simply monitor and deal with issues relating to Staff (Moderators, Administrators and players for that matter).  People don't need to know what rights Managers have or don't it's not for you to know yet I just explained what we're tasked to do.

You think everything is expected to work smoothly?  What year you living in 2040?

And bOOOOOOOOm, it's again down.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: superh2o on October 27, 2014, 08:04:14 pm
Man just explained you how things work.

Just deal with it.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Devin on October 27, 2014, 08:26:53 pm
The players aren't the only ones getting frustrated with the frequent downtime, believe me.
Unfortunately there's nothing we can do about it either.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Rusty on October 27, 2014, 08:37:44 pm
And bOOOOOOOOm, it's again down.

Then go post a downtime report, what do you want me to do wave a magic wand and everything will be okay? 
Goes it goes down, maybe it's a hint you should go do something else meanwhile.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Seskom on October 27, 2014, 08:46:08 pm
Why should I raise a point with Gandalf when my position as a Manager is to look after the Administration Team, issues with server going down is not my area.  Managers don't need access to the server directly as we don't need it and won't ever have it.  We aren't developers or Community Leaders we simply monitor and deal with issues relating to Staff (Moderators, Administrators and players for that matter).  People don't need to know what rights Managers have or don't it's not for you to know yet I just explained what we're tasked to do.

You think everything is expected to work smoothly?  What year you living in 2040?

I belive I'm living in year 2014, where if something goes down, people are notified of it. Currently people post these topics which get locked and trashed 24/7.

Imagine a real-life situation when you're driving to work- suddenly construction: 10km round trip to go where you need to, no notifications, a letter saying "what year are you living in, 2040? Go use other roads until this one is fixed"

I know the comparison is an extreme one, but if that's what gets the point made, then it's required.


I'd just like to say that everyone who says protection against DDoS on 2004 server is almost impossible to look at other servers, yes they do offer special benefits for players if they pay money for example a name change or ability to drive BMX-... ofcourse those servers also allow multiple accounts making the name change a possibility not an requirement, if you want to change the name, create a new account. During RS4 we could had made such system work, but since RS5 and constant downtimes with the small part of community this is extremely pointless.

I can quarantee unless the downtime issues are fixed we will not be able to pull in new players to stay with the community. Right now if anyone raises a point regarding some issues with the server then the only thing they get is angry manager blaming it on the player and assaulting them instead of explaining their side without some ridiculus remarks about years 2040 and trying to make players look like noobs. How are people supposed to enjoy themselves, if they raise an known issue and then all they get from management is laming on themselves instead of solution to problem?

EDIT:
Then go post a downtime report, what do you want me to do wave a magic wand and everything will be okay? 
Goes it goes down, maybe it's a hint you should go do something else meanwhile.

This is exactly the shitty attitude I'm refering to.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Frank_Hawk on October 27, 2014, 09:13:22 pm
To the defense of the current leadership / management - they really are powerless to help.

This type of attack on this community is illegal.

Surely, we should record the attacker's details and pass them on to the proper authorities (ISP etc) to carry out an investigation. Alternatively, perhaps we should explore what other popular servers have in terms of security arrangements with a view to have our own long term solution to the problem.

In relation to the leadership / management having no say over the introduction or enhancements to RS5 - I think this is shocking since what quality control do we have in place to ensure any enhancements are being made in line with the vision? I think this is the fundamental reason why our server has become a combination of RLRP and freeroam. We're confused whether we are a cat or dog.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Brian on October 27, 2014, 09:30:05 pm
I actually wanted to stay out of this, but since people just keep saying the same stuff, I guess it's also my turn to make a post.

An answer on a question everyone's wondering, yes everyone.
No, we do NOT know what is going on and we WILL inform you when we do. That's all we can say right now, as we don't know what the issue is either.
Yes, We are trying to contact Gandalf, without success up to yet.

So there you go, and answer for a question a lot of people here are having.
Now on to the point, as a lot of people get pissed or upset about this, so do we, don't think we just sit here and be like 'Oh, we don't care about the server and its players so lets just ignore them and be like mhh, they'll figure it out'. We've been trying to tell you guys this for a long time, we do not know what is going on, and if we do we will inform you guys. And that's what a lot of people are missing and keep blaming it on us.
And now you may be wondering, why do we not have access to what we need yet. Well, Argonath had quite some changes as you all may have seen around, which also includes panels and changes made by Gandalf, there fore we can not do anything, nor see what is wrong at the moment. All we can wait for is Gandalf to show up and tell us. Or the servers to pop up their selves again and we try to figure out what may have caused the downtime.
And now some of you may think, why are you all blaming it on Gandalf, well, answer is as easy as the question asked. Because he is the only one that can currently do something about it. So ye, I hope this ends the discussion of 'why are management not informing us'. Because there is nothing to inform you about.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: crohacker on October 27, 2014, 09:36:16 pm
I actually wanted to stay out of this, but since people just keep saying the same stuff, I guess it's also my turn to make a post.

An answer on a question everyone's wondering, yes everyone.
No, we do NOT know what is going on and we WILL inform you when we do. That's all we can say right now, as we don't know what the issue is either.
Yes, We are trying to contact Gandalf, without success up to yet.

So there you go, and answer for a question a lot of people here are having.
Now on to the point, as a lot of people get pissed or upset about this, so do we, don't think we just sit here and be like 'Oh, we don't care about the server and its players so lets just ignore them and be like mhh, they'll figure it out'. We've been trying to tell you guys this for a long time, we do not know what is going on, and if we do we will inform you guys. And that's what a lot of people are missing and keep blaming it on us.
And now you may be wondering, why do we not have access to what we need yet. Well, Argonath had quite some changes as you all may have seen around, which also includes panels and changes made by Gandalf, there fore we can not do anything, nor see what is wrong at the moment. All we can wait for is Gandalf to show up and tell us. Or the servers to pop up their selves again and we try to figure out what may have caused the downtime.
And now some of you may think, why are you all blaming it on Gandalf, well, answer is as easy as the question asked. Because he is the only one that can currently do something about it. So ye, I hope this ends the discussion of 'why are management not informing us'. Because there is nothing to inform you about.



 :app: :app: :app: :app: :app: :app:
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Seskom on October 27, 2014, 09:48:34 pm
I actually wanted to stay out of this, but since people just keep saying the same stuff, I guess it's also my turn to make a post.

An answer on a question everyone's wondering, yes everyone.
No, we do NOT know what is going on and we WILL inform you when we do. That's all we can say right now, as we don't know what the issue is either.
Yes, We are trying to contact Gandalf, without success up to yet.

So there you go, and answer for a question a lot of people here are having.
Now on to the point, as a lot of people get pissed or upset about this, so do we, don't think we just sit here and be like 'Oh, we don't care about the server and its players so lets just ignore them and be like mhh, they'll figure it out'. We've been trying to tell you guys this for a long time, we do not know what is going on, and if we do we will inform you guys. And that's what a lot of people are missing and keep blaming it on us.
And now you may be wondering, why do we not have access to what we need yet. Well, Argonath had quite some changes as you all may have seen around, which also includes panels and changes made by Gandalf, there fore we can not do anything, nor see what is wrong at the moment. All we can wait for is Gandalf to show up and tell us. Or the servers to pop up their selves again and we try to figure out what may have caused the downtime.
And now some of you may think, why are you all blaming it on Gandalf, well, answer is as easy as the question asked. Because he is the only one that can currently do something about it. So ye, I hope this ends the discussion of 'why are management not informing us'. Because there is nothing to inform you about.

This is exactly what people have been wanting to know.
A simple notification topic regarding current situation - the same thing you said (I've made it red in the quote) in a notification board / SA:MP general depends how much of server it effects as a sticky topic. A topic where managers will post updates regarding the situation, it can be locked, just as far as we've got a large ass sticky topic with information so every player woudln't make new topics and get responses like this:

Then go post a downtime report, what do you want me to do wave a magic wand and everything will be okay? 
Goes it goes down, maybe it's a hint you should go do something else meanwhile.

If the roles of management and players were reversed and player would use such tone on manager he'd be banned.

E.g.
Player is desynced, admin contacts him
Admin: You're desynced.
Player: What do you want, should I wave a magic wand and fix it? Wait until I'm done with my RP and I'll relog.
Player: Maybe it's a hint you should go do something else in mean time, roleplay or catch some hackers.
Admin bans the player due to shitty attitude towards administrative staff.

This tone from some managers and the way they communicate is completely unbelivable.


ALL we need is a simple notification topic which would get updated, if the server is up for 12 hours then the topic can be removed, once the server goes down we'd get a new topic. Easy as that.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Cyril on October 27, 2014, 09:52:08 pm
This tone from some managers and the way they communicate is completely unbelivable.

The irony coming from you..
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: stormeus on October 27, 2014, 10:04:26 pm
The irony coming from you..

Ah, the classic ad hominem (https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/ad-hominem) fallacy. Seskom's apparent track record aside, his point is still valid: managers should be more considerate with their communication or else criticism like this comes up. No one has to kiss ass, especially not to people who disrespect the community, but stooping to a lower level only makes HQ look bad.

Edit: I also like his idea of a visible downtime notification board for communicating information about outages, like GitHub (http://status.github.com) shows statistics over time and Ello (http://status.ello.co/) shows past incidents and current outages. Would be pretty neat for users.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Devin on October 27, 2014, 10:10:41 pm
Don't approve on how my team behaves? Then report them to me.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Leon. on October 27, 2014, 10:22:19 pm
The irony coming from you..
Shouldn't you be reading groups' CB chats in your free time instead of posting personal attacks on the forum?
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Kaze on October 27, 2014, 10:24:29 pm
To the defense of the current leadership / management - they really are powerless to help.

This type of attack on this community is illegal.

Surely, we should record the attacker's details and pass them on to the proper authorities (ISP etc) to carry out an investigation. Alternatively, perhaps we should explore what other popular servers have in terms of security arrangements with a view to have our own long term solution to the problem.

In relation to the leadership / management having no say over the introduction or enhancements to RS5 - I think this is shocking since what quality control do we have in place to ensure any enhancements are being made in line with the vision? I think this is the fundamental reason why our server has become a combination of RLRP and freeroam. We're confused whether we are a cat or dog.

Who gives a f**k about a DDoS attack on a server? The law have other priorities like busting drug dealers  :lol:
Some people take this too serious.



Shouldn't you be reading groups' CB chats in your free time instead of posting personal attacks on the forum?

SHOTS FIRED KABOOOOOOOOOOM



I regret to inform you Cyril has stepped down as manager due to the heartless comment from Leon. RIP.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Devin on October 27, 2014, 10:27:19 pm
Choke chains are on order from Mordor. Stop this nonsense now.
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: stormeus on October 27, 2014, 10:27:45 pm
Don't approve on how my team behaves? Then report them to me.

I'm not saying drop your staff, I'm saying that communication is critical when looking after a community of hundreds upon hundreds of players, especially when trying to attract more to play. It's little things that make players feel more appreciated, as there seem to be a lot of criticism about the lack of clear information, and I'm not sure if there's a silent majority. Stuff like:
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Bundy on October 27, 2014, 10:37:26 pm
Shouldn't you be reading groups' CB chats in your free time instead of posting personal attacks on the forum?
(http://i3.kym-cdn.com/entries/icons/original/000/005/393/i-know-that-feel.jpg)
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Leon. on October 27, 2014, 11:07:41 pm
I'm not saying drop your staff, I'm saying that communication is critical when looking after a community of hundreds upon hundreds of players, especially when trying to attract more to play. It's little things that make players feel more appreciated, as there seem to be a lot of criticism about the lack of clear information, and I'm not sure if there's a silent majority. Stuff like:
  • Transparency: maintaining a thread or board for downtime reports. If the server goes down, keep the players in the loop and post a new thread, e.g. "The server was down at {X time} because of {Y reason: a script issue|planned/unplanned maintenance|etc.}. We {are investigating|have resolved} the issue."

    If you don't know why the server is down, just say "The server is down for unknown reasons which we are investigating. Updates will be posted as they are available. Even if there isn't much to say, it elicits a better response than only answering when players post threads asking why the server is down.

  • Remaining professional. If a player is blatantly posting misinformation, explain why they're wrong, but do so in a way that doesn't make it look like a personal attack on them. If they're truly wrong, the community will side with you if you keep your calm, and they'll look like the bad guys.

  • Staying focused on the community. If the server does go down, don't tell players to go play somewhere else in the meantime instead of complaining about downtime. If anything, encourage them to go play on some of the other GTA:MP servers that Argonath offers for the time being (which keeps people in the community) or on ParUni.
Your vision for a better community is perhaps one of the most reasonable things ever posted since the advent of RS5. Perhaps you should rise through the ranks and see it implemented :P
Title: Re: Constant DDoS or other problems?
Post by: Rusty on October 27, 2014, 11:34:00 pm
Server backup.

SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2025, SimplePortal