Let's get real - part 2 - RS5 or RS4?

[Slavik]

Two very simple questions:

If the bugs in RS5 were fixed, would you play?
If the bugs in RS5 were fixed and you wouldn't want to play, what would you want to see changed?

1) Currently playing, and I will be playing.
2) Not sure.

[Zlatan]

If the bugs in RS5 were fixed, would you play?
If the bugs in RS5 were fixed and you wouldn't want to play, what would you want to see changed?

1. No
2. Everything

[Jones]

1. No
2. Everything

I again refer to my point about constructive feedback.. 

[AK47]

Two very simple questions:

If the bugs in RS5 were fixed, would you play?
If the bugs in RS5 were fixed and you wouldn't want to play, what would you want to see changed?

And then I add, would it take another 4 years to get everything fixed?

[Acika]

And then I add, would it take another 4 years to get everything fixed?

You nailed it

[Zlatan]

I am posting this again......

You guys really destroyed the server... real f**king good...

RS5:

- Commands are complicated, not finished, with useless menu boxes and tons of bugs.
- PD's bugged, no PnS (what if they're no mechanics online, and mechanics can be used for evil in criminal work, aka abuse), many more...
- Bank, wallets, card and that shit are way more complicated, $10 charge for every deposit and withdrawal...
- 99 percent of the server died, left and want RS4 back...

RS4:

- Simply as hell, fun, RP.
- Commands are fully finished, police ranks, PnS, no shitty mechanics. Simplicity at highest.
- Gangs, police, mafia, good old times huh...
- 150 upto 200 players DAILY, whilst in RS5 10 players max, daily...
- RS4 only had one problem, which was CBFASI's damn grammar mistakes in some text, but overall RS4 was the best yet. EVERYONE KNOWS IT, even Gandalf, all the admins...

AND YOU STILL SAY RS5 IS BETTER. Its not.

RS5 WAS SUPPOSED TO IMPROVE, NOT DESTROY ARGONATH, WAKE UP.

Thats my constructive feedback..

[Jones]

And then I add, would it take another 4 years to get everything fixed?

Development early on wasn't as involved as the last year was. I'm sure I wouldn't be that far off in saying that the last year of development was probably the "busiest" year and the most progress was made in that year. Bugs don't take as long to fix either presuming a whole re-write isn't needed (of the bugged system that is).

[Slavik]

I am posting this again......

You guys really destroyed the server... real f**king good...

RS5:

- Commands are complicated, not finished, with useless menu boxes and tons of bugs.
- PD's bugged, no PnS (what if they're no mechanics online, and mechanics can be used for evil in criminal work, aka abuse), many more...
- Bank, wallets, card and that shit are way more complicated, $10 charge for every deposit and withdrawal...
- 99 percent of the server died, left and want RS4 back...

RS4:

- Simply as hell, fun, RP.
- Commands are fully finished, police ranks, PnS, no shitty mechanics. Simplicity at highest.
- Gangs, police, mafia, good old times huh...
- 150 upto 200 players DAILY, whilst in RS5 10 players max, daily...
- RS4 only had one problem, which was CBFASI's damn grammar mistakes in some text, but overall RS4 was the best yet. EVERYONE KNOWS IT, even Gandalf, all the admins...

AND YOU STILL SAY RS5 IS BETTER. Its not.

RS5 WAS SUPPOSED TO IMPROVE, NOT DESTROY ARGONATH, WAKE UP.

Thats my constructive feedback..

I am also posting it again.
Stop complaining/Moaning and go play, get used to the new commands and features.

[[Rstar]Razor]

RS4, RS5 was released too soon.

Tell that to the players that were shitting and saying RS5 was never going to come or said RS5 was taking too long.

Anyways I find it funny that the leadership always said "RP it" whenever players asked for a command for this and that, now we have a script shock full of scripts and TA-DA here we are.

Main problem was that developers gave so many attention to some parts of the script while overlooking/rushing other parts... The players who got their enjoyment from these so called 'other parts' left leaving a big hole in the playerbase. Low players leads to low players.
Want to fix the playerbase? Start by yourself.

As for the developers.. My true opinion is.. Stop being afraid to make criminal work profitable. It's meant to be that way. In real life that's the way it goes, more money for the risk of jail. So make it that way. Also... Funny how it gets past some people the trouble developers went to give criminals more trouble. Sounds ironic doesn't it? Yes, I'm talking about things such as the new drug system, the blockades infront on every Ammunation, shortcut blocking... I could go on..

Sorry If my opinion is not well received. But to be honest it's how I see it.

[Slavik]

Tell that to the players that were shitting and saying RS5 was never going to come or said RS5 was taking too long.

Ironic

[Jeremy.]

And then I add, would it take another 4 years to get everything fixed?

Five man, five. 

[Mopreme]

This topic was about RS5 and RS4

To what cause, exactly?
Gandalf has already set his demands for bringing back RS4 which obviously won't be met which leaves us stuck with RS5. With that in mind, I would love to know what you think the purpose & goal of this thread actually is.

[Slavik]

Five man, five. 

No.

[[Rstar]Razor]

Ironic

Let me stop you right there. I never shitted on noone. I told my opinion and I got crapped over for it, so don't talk about things that apparently escape your comprehension.

If my opinion is a negative feedback does it mean that I am shitting?

I'm probably one of the oldest players around and you can bet that I like Argonath and I want to see it going for much more time.

[Jeremy.]

If my opinion is a negative feedback does it mean that I am shitting?

Welcome to Argonath RPG.