I'm very picky when it comes to games, it has to be perfect or close to perfect in every aspect of the game for me to enjoy it...
Perfect in every aspect is when every part of the game flows together in a nice harmony, for example bad graphics doesn't necesairly have to be bad graphics... anyhow...
I enjoyed playing World of Warcraft, I also enjoyed playing Fable, and Oblivion / Fallout - however I easily get bored of games like, fable, oblivion and fallout. I did some hard-core gaming on Mount and Blade, at first I tought this game was shit but once I got into it it was amazing, however it got too repetative at the "end".
GTA series I don't even have to mention, it is obviously a good game series, aswell as Godfather and Mafia.
Stuff like Mirrors edge, Getting Up: Contents Under Pressure and Assassins creed have always facinated me, mainly because of the parkour-ish gameplay I suppose...
I'm not a big fan of first person, however I do not have a problem with it, I just haven't found any first person game that suits me (oblivion / fallout and Mirrors Edge is ofcourse an expection and we all know why...). Counterstrike is fun, but like any other fps game I've tried it gets easily boring.
I hate all these, excuse me saying, knock-off asian shit games (for example: Knight Online). They are all the same, shitass graphics, klick-target still-standing combat system, some of them don't even have a jump option - No jumping = no funtime.
I am thinking of trying out Atlantica Online, however I'm not a big fan of turn-based games - bad patience I suppose.
Online or offline doesn't really concern me, ofcourse playing online and / or having a chat where you can talk would be much more fun then sitting alone playing - however it's not prio 1.
I do not have the best computer, and because of this I can't play the newest game, like for example Prototype (

)
I hate when a game isn't freeroam, so I guess that makes prio 1 - Freeroam!
What game would you, recommend for me?