Unban requests boards, restrict them.

[Abraham]

If you will restrict Server A boards so that only Server A Managers can post in them, the same thing as I described above will happen, except replacing _Administrator with _Manager.

That was not the idea posted, again, did you read the topic?

I was giving the description of how inherited permission system in SMF works, not the full rebuttal for the idea.

Instead of arguing with you, I'll let you yourself do the work for me.

The proposal would mean that it would be impossible for Managers and Administrators to inherit all their permissions from the same group (and for all separate groups involved to have separate set permissions), since board permissions work based on permission sets and not membergroups.

In short, this will destroy any uniform inherited permissions structure.

[JDC]

The response was given due to the repeated remarks in the topic that Server A unban requests should only allow Server A staff to post.

[Abraham]

The response was given due to the repeated remarks in the topic that Server A unban requests should only allow Server A staff to post.

The "repeated remarks" in question was made after your post. (Also it was ONE remark, not several.)

Just stop dude...

[JDC]

Just stop dude...

Because the remarks in question deviated from the original proposed idea or simply because you cannot handle people opposing your idea?

[Abraham]

Because the remarks in question deviated from the original proposed idea or simply because you cannot handle people opposing your idea?

The "repeated remarks" in question was made after your post. (Also it was ONE remark, not several.)

I'm asking you to stop because you're digging yourself a hole you can't climb out of.

I have no problem with people opposing my idea, you're not the first (again, did you read the topic?).
Also you've not given any concrete reasons as to why you would be opposed to it, rather you are arguing for the sake of arguing.

[JDC]

rather you are arguing for the sake of arguing.

Exactly. I am not arguing to provoke, blackpaint, or destroy.

There is nothing to lose in seeing things from more and more perspectives, after all... :devroll:

[Gandalf]

Every admin should read the post regarding this on the main admin forum.
With that for now the topic is closed, if a new topic is deemed necessary in time please do not hesitate to create one.