Clean version rate

[Pistol Man]

hi im getting job at the radio station (True) and its  music editing, so they gave me this video to edit it to test me, i made it clean and suitable to be on the radio, plz compare the dirty version and the clean version and rate my editing out of 10

Eminem - Fight Music (Dirty)
Eminem - Fight Music (Clean - My Edit)

thx

[Fatboy_Rob]

Your editing is a 5.6/10 because, you cut a looong clip out at 1:12 - 1:13 ( its noticeable)

And the muting is great, its just that the radio station people gave you a song that has too much cursing in it, and it sounds bad...

Keep up the great work though

-Hayden

[Pistol Man]

Your editing is a 5.6/10 because, you cut a looong clip out at 1:12 - 1:13 ( its noticeable)

And the muting is great, its just that the radio station people gave you a song that has too much cursing in it, and it sounds bad...

Keep up the great work though

-Hayden

yeh i know i couldnt mute all that on 1:13 because there is will be too much empty space

thx hayden for the note and the rating

[Fatboy_Rob]

your editing is great, its just that its alot, and i mean alot of Cursing/bad words, and you should ask for a different song to edit, because, they would never play it on teh radio

[Pistol Man]

your editing is great, its just that its alot, and i mean alot of Cursing/bad words, and you should ask for a different song to edit, because, they would never play it on teh radio

im just beginner and im learning, this is my instructor's pro edited song